Best Cars Under $5,000 For Sale in Columbus, OH (2024)

Looking to buy an inexpensive, economical, reliable car? These choices--all under $5,000--will deliver the goods. CarGurus analyzes prices on hundreds of thousands of cars to determine which ones are a great deal (and which are overpriced). Shop for inexpensive cars today.

26 results

Nationwide

Select Sort Order

2016 Mazda MAZDA3 s Grand Touring Hatchback 233,068 mi 184 hp 2.5L I4 $4,994 GOOD DEAL Leather Seats Sunroof/Moonroof + more Columbus, OH (7 mi away) Year: 2016 Make: Mazda Model: MAZDA3 Body type: Hatchback Doors: 4 doors Drivetrain: Front-Wheel Drive Engine: 184 hp 2.5L I4 Exterior color: Snowflake White Pearl Mica Combined gas mileage: 32 MPG Fuel type: Gasoline Interior color: Sand Transmission: 6-Speed Automatic Mileage: 233,068 NHTSA overall safety rating: 5 Stock number: KPG1301259 VIN: JM1BM1N37G1301259

Preparing for a close up... Photos coming soon 2012 Acura TL FWD 216,206 mi 280 hp 3.5L V6 $4,699 GREAT DEAL Leather Seats Sunroof/Moonroof + more Brice, OH (10 mi away) Year: 2012 Make: Acura Model: TL Body type: Sedan Doors: 4 doors Drivetrain: Front-Wheel Drive Engine: 280 hp 3.5L V6 Combined gas mileage: 24 MPG Fuel type: Gasoline Mileage: 216,206 NHTSA overall safety rating: 3 Stock number: 382637 VIN: 19UUA8F22CA024211

2008 Toyota Prius 220,436 mi 110 hp 1.5L I4 Hybrid $3,999 GOOD DEAL Alloy Wheels + more Brice, OH (10 mi away) Year: 2008 Make: Toyota Model: Prius Body type: Hatchback Engine: 110 hp 1.5L I4 Hybrid Fuel type: Hybrid Mileage: 220,436 NHTSA overall safety rating: Not Rated Stock number: 382101 VIN: JTDKB20U187781521

2007 Acura TL FWD with Navigation 171,425 mi 258 hp 3.2L V6 $4,999 GREAT DEAL Leather Seats Sunroof/Moonroof + more Newark, OH (32 mi away) Year: 2007 Make: Acura Model: TL Body type: Sedan Doors: 4 doors Drivetrain: Front-Wheel Drive Engine: 258 hp 3.2L V6 Exterior color: Silver Combined gas mileage: 22 MPG Fuel type: Gasoline Interior color: Black Transmission: 5-Speed Automatic Mileage: 171,425 NHTSA overall safety rating: Not Rated Stock number: A907 VIN: 19UUA66217A033699

2010 Toyota Prius One 229,412 mi 134 hp 1.8L I4 Hybrid $3,500 GREAT DEAL Alloy Wheels + more Rockbridge, OH (37 mi away) Year: 2010 Make: Toyota Model: Prius Body type: Hatchback Doors: 4 doors Drivetrain: Front-Wheel Drive Engine: 134 hp 1.8L I4 Hybrid Exterior color: White Combined gas mileage: 50 MPG Fuel type: Hybrid Interior color: White Transmission: Continuously Variable Transmission Mileage: 229,412 NHTSA overall safety rating: Not Rated Stock number: 1490 VIN: JTDKN3DU6A1301490

Preparing for a close up... Photos coming soon 2008 Mazda MAZDA3 s Sport Hatchback 246,160 mi 156 hp 2.3L I4 $2,500 GREAT DEAL Alloy Wheels + more Plain City, OH (18 mi away) Year: 2008 Make: Mazda Model: MAZDA3 Body type: Hatchback Doors: 4 doors Drivetrain: Front-Wheel Drive Engine: 156 hp 2.3L I4 Exterior color: Purple Combined gas mileage: 25 MPG Fuel type: Gasoline Interior color: Gray Transmission: 5-Speed Automatic Mileage: 246,160 NHTSA overall safety rating: Not Rated Stock number: 1440 VIN: JM1BK343681777099

Preparing for a close up... Photos coming soon 2012 Mazda MAZDA3 i Sport 164,144 mi 148 hp 2L I4 $4,900 FAIR DEAL Sport Package Alloy Wheels + more Columbus, OH (5 mi away) Year: 2012 Make: Mazda Model: MAZDA3 Body type: Sedan Doors: 4 doors Drivetrain: Front-Wheel Drive Engine: 148 hp 2L I4 Exterior color: Silver Combined gas mileage: 28 MPG Fuel type: Gasoline Interior color: Black Transmission: Automatic Mileage: 164,144 NHTSA overall safety rating: 4 Stock number: 4926 VIN: JM1BL1UF4C1533410

Preparing for a close up... Photos coming soon 2010 Toyota Prius Two 261,472 mi 134 hp 1.8L I4 Hybrid $3,999 FAIR DEAL Alloy Wheels + more Brice, OH (10 mi away) Year: 2010 Make: Toyota Model: Prius Body type: Hatchback Doors: 4 doors Drivetrain: Front-Wheel Drive Engine: 134 hp 1.8L I4 Hybrid Combined gas mileage: 50 MPG Fuel type: Hybrid Mileage: 261,472 NHTSA overall safety rating: Not Rated Stock number: 382649 VIN: JTDKN3DU7A1010402

Preparing for a close up... Photos coming soon 2012 Mazda MAZDA3 i Sport 188,541 mi 148 hp 2L I4 $3,990 FAIR DEAL Newark, OH (30 mi away) Year: 2012 Make: Mazda Model: MAZDA3 Body type: Sedan Doors: 4 doors Drivetrain: Front-Wheel Drive Engine: 148 hp 2L I4 Exterior color: Black Combined gas mileage: 29 MPG Fuel type: Gasoline Transmission: 5-Speed Manual Mileage: 188,541 NHTSA overall safety rating: 4 Stock number: 649073 VIN: JM1BL1UF0C1649073

Preparing for a close up... Photos coming soon 2012 Kia Soul + 212,686 mi 2L I4 $3,400 FAIR DEAL Alloy Wheels Bluetooth + more Columbus, OH (7 mi away) Year: 2012 Make: Kia Model: Soul Body type: Wagon Doors: 4 doors Drivetrain: Front-Wheel Drive Engine: 2L I4 Exterior color: Red Combined gas mileage: 25 MPG Fuel type: Gasoline Transmission: Automatic Mileage: 212,686 NHTSA overall safety rating: 4 Stock number: 2596 VIN: KNDJT2A69C7430728

Preparing for a close up... Photos coming soon 2010 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 LT Extended Cab 4WD 311,693 mi 315 hp 5.3L V8 Flex Fuel Vehicle $3,500 FAIR DEAL Chrome Wheels + more Columbus, OH (7 mi away) Year: 2010 Make: Chevrolet Model: Silverado 1500 Body type: Pickup Truck Doors: 4 doors Drivetrain: Four-Wheel Drive Engine: 315 hp 5.3L V8 Flex Fuel Vehicle Exterior color: White Combined gas mileage: 18 MPG Fuel type: Flex Fuel Vehicle Transmission: Automatic Mileage: 311,693 NHTSA overall safety rating: Not Rated Stock number: 2724 VIN: 1GCSKSE3XAZ141849

Preparing for a close up... Photos coming soon 2011 Acura TL FWD 244,062 mi 280 hp 3.5L V6 $4,990 FAIR DEAL Leather Seats Sunroof/Moonroof + more Newark, OH (30 mi away) Year: 2011 Make: Acura Model: TL Body type: Sedan Doors: 4 doors Drivetrain: Front-Wheel Drive Engine: 280 hp 3.5L V6 Exterior color: Silver Combined gas mileage: 22 MPG Fuel type: Gasoline Transmission: Automatic Mileage: 244,062 NHTSA overall safety rating: Not Rated Stock number: 006157 VIN: 19UUA8F20BA006157

Preparing for a close up... Photos coming soon 2006 Toyota Prius FWD 213,290 mi 110 hp 1.5L I4 Hybrid $4,999 FAIR DEAL Alloy Wheels + more Brice, OH (10 mi away) Year: 2006 Make: Toyota Model: Prius Body type: Hatchback Doors: 4 doors Drivetrain: Front-Wheel Drive Engine: 110 hp 1.5L I4 Hybrid Combined gas mileage: 47 MPG Fuel type: Hybrid Mileage: 213,290 NHTSA overall safety rating: Not Rated Stock number: 381535 VIN: JTDKB20U663189777

Preparing for a close up... Photos coming soon 2005 Jeep Grand Cherokee Laredo 4WD 150,352 mi 210 hp 3.7L V6 $3,900 Alloy Wheels + more Columbus, OH (5 mi away) Year: 2005 Make: Jeep Model: Grand Cherokee Body type: SUV / Crossover Doors: 4 doors Drivetrain: Four-Wheel Drive Engine: 210 hp 3.7L V6 Exterior color: Red (Burgundy) Combined gas mileage: 17 MPG Fuel type: Gasoline Interior color: Brown (Tan) Transmission: Automatic Mileage: 150,352 NHTSA overall safety rating: Not Rated Stock number: 4956 VIN: 1J4GR48K15C628621

Preparing for a close up... Photos coming soon 2011 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 LTZ Extended Cab 4WD 184,000 mi 315 hp 5.3L V8 Flex Fuel Vehicle $2,998 Leather Seats Navigation System + more Mount Vernon, OH (38 mi away) Year: 2011 Make: Chevrolet Model: Silverado 1500 Body type: Pickup Truck Doors: 4 doors Drivetrain: Four-Wheel Drive Engine: 315 hp 5.3L V8 Flex Fuel Vehicle Exterior color: Black Combined gas mileage: 18 MPG Fuel type: Flex Fuel Vehicle Interior color: Black (Charcoal) Transmission: 6-Speed Automatic Mileage: 184,000 NHTSA overall safety rating: 4 Stock number: 284081 VIN: 1GCRKTE31BZ284081

Preparing for a close up... Photos coming soon 2013 Nissan LEAF SV 86,975 mi Electric $5,000 Navigation System Alloy Wheels + more Dublin, OH (11 mi away) Year: 2013 Make: Nissan Model: LEAF Body type: Hatchback Doors: 4 doors Drivetrain: Front-Wheel Drive Engine: Electric Exterior color: Super Black Combined gas mileage: 116 MPG Fuel type: Electric Interior color: Light Gray Transmission: Automatic Mileage: 86,975 NHTSA overall safety rating: 4 Stock number: BC8858 VIN: 1N4AZ0CP0DC408088

Preparing for a close up... Photos coming soon 2008 Jeep Grand Cherokee Overland 4WD 148,248 mi 330 hp 5.7L V8 $4,595 Leather Seats Sunroof/Moonroof + more Reynoldsburg, OH (14 mi away) Year: 2008 Make: Jeep Model: Grand Cherokee Body type: SUV / Crossover Doors: 4 doors Drivetrain: Four-Wheel Drive Engine: 330 hp 5.7L V8 Exterior color: Red Combined gas mileage: 15 MPG Fuel type: Gasoline Interior color: Brown (TAN) Transmission: Automatic Mileage: 148,248 NHTSA overall safety rating: Not Rated Stock number: 100349 VIN: 1J8HR68278C136940

Preparing for a close up... Photos coming soon 1999 Jeep Grand Cherokee Limited 4WD 128,942 mi 195 hp 4L I6 $3,995 Leather Seats Alloy Wheels + more Columbus, OH (7 mi away) Year: 1999 Make: Jeep Model: Grand Cherokee Body type: SUV / Crossover Doors: 4 doors Drivetrain: Four-Wheel Drive Engine: 195 hp 4L I6 Exterior color: Tuxedo Black Combined gas mileage: 16 MPG Fuel type: Gasoline Transmission: 4-Speed Automatic Mileage: 128,942 NHTSA overall safety rating: Not Rated Stock number: K26288A VIN: 1J4GW68S2XC568775

Preparing for a close up... Photos coming soon 2004 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 Work Truck LB 4WD 191,444 mi 195 hp 4.3L V6 $3,295 Steel Wheels + more Hilliard, OH (9 mi away) Year: 2004 Make: Chevrolet Model: Silverado 1500 Body type: Pickup Truck Doors: 2 doors Drivetrain: Four-Wheel Drive Engine: 195 hp 4.3L V6 Exterior color: Gray Combined gas mileage: 15 MPG Fuel type: Gasoline Interior color: Gray Transmission: 4-Speed Automatic Mileage: 191,444 NHTSA overall safety rating: Not Rated Stock number: 612927982 VIN: 1GCEK14X44Z321067

Preparing for a close up... Photos coming soon 2003 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 LS Extended Cab 4WD 194,245 mi 5.3L V8 $1,999 Chrome Wheels + more Brice, OH (10 mi away) Year: 2003 Make: Chevrolet Model: Silverado 1500 Body type: Pickup Truck Doors: 4 doors Drivetrain: Four-Wheel Drive Engine: 5.3L V8 Fuel type: Gasoline Mileage: 194,245 NHTSA overall safety rating: Not Rated Stock number: 382654 VIN: 2GCEK19T031251502

Preparing for a close up... Photos coming soon 2006 Jeep Grand Cherokee Laredo 4WD 157,968 mi 210 hp 3.7L V6 $4,395 Alloy Wheels + more Columbus, OH (9 mi away) Year: 2006 Make: Jeep Model: Grand Cherokee Body type: SUV / Crossover Doors: 4 doors Drivetrain: Four-Wheel Drive Engine: 210 hp 3.7L V6 Exterior color: Blue Combined gas mileage: 17 MPG Fuel type: Gasoline Transmission: Automatic Mileage: 157,968 NHTSA overall safety rating: Not Rated Stock number: 002118 VIN: 1J4GR48K46C250358

Preparing for a close up... Photos coming soon 2001 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 Extended Cab RWD 220,089 mi 200 hp 4.3L V6 $3,900 Steel Wheels + more Grove City, OH (6 mi away) Year: 2001 Make: Chevrolet Model: Silverado 1500 Body type: Pickup Truck Doors: 4 doors Drivetrain: Rear-Wheel Drive Engine: 200 hp 4.3L V6 Exterior color: Red Combined gas mileage: 17 MPG Fuel type: Gasoline Interior color: Gray (Graphite) Transmission: 4-Speed Automatic Mileage: 220,089 NHTSA overall safety rating: Not Rated Stock number: 2758 VIN: 2GCEC19W411132758

Best Cars Under $5,000 For Sale in Columbus, OH (2024)

References