From special occasions to luxurious dining experiences, lobster has long been synonymous with indulgence and gourmet living. With numerous varieties of lobster available worldwide, each with its own unique flavor profile and rarity, it’s no wonder that these delectable crustaceans command such high prices in upscale markets and restaurants.
While all lobsters have their unique charms and flavors, some stand out above the rest in terms of taste, texture, and overall culinary experience. From the well-known Maine lobster to the rare and colorful pearl lobster, each of these eight varieties brings something special to the table. Read on to discover what makes these lobsters so expensive and worth trying.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
Maine Lobsters
Maine lobsters, also known as American lobsters, set the standard when it comes to flavor, texture, versatility, and bang for your buck. As the most sought-after crustaceans on the market, these true lobsters carry more meat in their robust claws (which spiny lobsters are missing altogether).
Maine lobsters are popular not only in the United States but also around the world, and are often considered a benchmark for quality in the lobster world.
Differences in Flavor Profile
Compared to other lobster varieties, Maine lobsters offer a sweeter, more delicate flavor that many seafood enthusiasts find irresistible.
Their tender meat is less stringy than some other varieties, making them an ideal choice for a variety of culinary applications, from classic boiled or steamed lobster to more adventurous dishes like lobster mac and cheese or lobster bisque.
Best Tasting Lobsters
Many connoisseurs argue that the best-tasting lobsters come from the cold waters off the coast of Maine.
The colder temperatures result in slower growth rates for the lobsters, allowing their meat to develop a more complex flavor profile over time. This is just one of the reasons why Maine lobsters are so highly regarded by chefs and foodies alike.
Price Range
Maine lobsters are generally more affordable than some of the other lobster varieties on this list, with prices averaging around $15 per kilogram.
While still a luxury item, their relatively lower cost makes them an accessible option for those looking to enjoy a delicious lobster meal without breaking the bank.
Availability
One of the reasons Maine lobsters are so popular is their widespread availability. They can be found in grocery stores, fish markets, and restaurants across the United States and beyond, making it easy for consumers to get their hands on these tasty crustaceans whenever the craving strikes.
Old Shell Lobsters
Old shell lobsters, also known as hard-shell lobsters, are more expensive than their soft-shell counterparts primarily due to the costs associated with transporting them.
Their thicker shells make them more durable and less prone to damage during shipping, but they also add significant weight. As a result, these lobsters can command higher prices on the market.
Coarser Flavor
While many people enjoy the taste of old shell lobsters, some find their flavor to be coarser and less delicate than that of soft-shell or Maine lobsters. This is a matter of personal preference, and some may appreciate the more robust flavor profile offered by old shell lobsters.
Tropical Rock Lobsters
Tropical rock lobsters, or spiny lobsters, are known for their striking appearance and relatively scarce availability. These factors contribute to their high price, as rarity often translates to increased demand and, subsequently, higher costs.
Unlike true lobsters, tropical rock lobsters lack the large claws that characterize their cold-water cousins, but their meat is still considered quite delicious.
High Price
The limited supply of tropical rock lobsters means that they can fetch a pretty penny on the market. Depending on the size and quality of the specimen, these lobsters can sell for anywhere from $30 to $60 per kilogram, making them one of the more expensive varieties on this list.
Pearl Lobsters
Pearl lobsters, also known as tropical rock lobsters or pearl lobsters, are one of the rarest and most expensive lobster varieties. Their colorful appearance, featuring vibrant hues of red, orange, and yellow, make them an eye-catching addition to any seafood dish.
International Smuggling Attempts
The high value placed on pearl lobsters has even led to international smuggling attempts of their larvae. Commercially-bred pearl lobsters sell for about $50 per kilogram, while wild-caught pearl lobsters sell for $99 per kilogram. This makes pearl lobsters more than six times more expensive than Maine lobsters, which go for $15 a kilogram.
Factors Affecting Lobster Prices
Seasonality
Like many other seafood products, the price of lobster can fluctuate depending on the time of year. Lobster season typically runs from late June through December, with prices generally peaking in the summer months when demand is highest. During the off-season, prices may decrease as supplies dwindle and demand wanes.
Demand
As with any commodity, the price of lobster is heavily influenced by supply and demand. When demand for lobster is high, prices will naturally rise to meet the increased demand. Conversely, when demand is low, prices will fall as suppliers attempt to move their product before it spoils.
Tips for Buying and Preparing Lobster
Tips for Buying
When purchasing lobster, there are a few key factors to consider. First and foremost, look for fresh, live lobsters. Their shells should be hard and intact, with no cracks or damage. The lobster should also have a healthy, vibrant color and should be lively when picked up or touched.
Tips for Preparing
Proper preparation is crucial for ensuring that your lobster is cooked to perfection. Some popular methods include boiling, steaming, grilling, and broiling. Regardless of your chosen cooking method, be sure to avoid overcooking your lobster, as this can result in tough, rubbery meat.
Cooking Suggestions
Once your lobster is cooked, the possibilities for serving it are virtually endless. Classic dishes like lobster rolls, lobster bisque, and lobster thermidor are always a hit, but don’t be afraid to get creative with your culinary creations. Lobster pairs well with a variety of flavors, from rich and creamy sauces to bright, citrusy accents.
Pairing Suggestions
To elevate your lobster dining experience even further, consider pairing your meal with a complementary wine or co*cktail. White wines like Chardonnay or Sauvignon Blanc are classic choices, but a crisp, refreshing rosé or even a light, fruity red could also work well. For co*cktails, consider a refreshing gin and tonic or a zesty margarita to balance out the rich flavors of your lobster dish.
What is the most expensive lobster dish?
The most expensive lobster dish is the Fourshu Lobster, also known as the “Rolls Royce of Lobsters,” which was first introduced in New York and is considered among the best lobsters in the world.
What is the rarest lobster?
The rarest lobster is the white or albino lobster, with an occurrence of only 1 in 100 million lobsters.
What is the most expensive type of seafood?
The most expensive type of seafood is bluefin tuna, which can cost an average of $3,600 per pound.
Are there different grades of lobster?
Yes, there are different grades of lobster, with Grade A being the highest quality, given to hard-shell lobsters with the highest meat density.
